Just call me Simon. I was tough to please tonight. Am I becoming a Simon curmudgeon? There were only four singers who impressed me tonight. Taylor (the gray-haired guy) almost made it into my top three picks, and I am very surprised by that (as was Simon).
Here are my top picks from tonight’s show, in alphabetical order. Congrats, guys, and good luck.
Ace | Chris | Elliott
Robin, I’ve been as sick as a dog, and only saw bits and pieces of each show. I missed Elliot, Paris and Miss McPhee completely, but heard they were great. Right this minute, I’m going with Paris and Ace, who (I’m sorry) is the cutest thing I’ve ever seen. He’s got the whole eye thing going on, and that alone will get him in the top three. Big fun!
I agree – I came in toward the end and they were showing clips of the line-up and I can’t say that what I heard impressed me too much. The girls on the other hand were a different story!!
I went with Taylor all the way. That man is good in 11 out of 10 ways!
Robin,
I don’t watch much of “Idol”, but love music, and I’d have to agree with you totally on the top three guys, in the same order as you too. I felt like Simon too. The other two judges were too accommodating!
Also, I liked “Bobby Brady”! 🙂